William Darrell Lindsey. His attorney, Assistant Public Defender Douglas Withee, said his client waschanging his plea because it is in his best interest to do so. September 5, 2021 When William Darrell Lindsey was arrested in North Carolina for the murder of Lucy Raymer, little did the police know they would tie him to multiple murders across two states. The bodies of two of the seven are still missing. He also set a hut on fire that other boys in his neighborhood had built. But the thing is, they did NOT have a strong case at allI. In an Action News Jax partnership with the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office and Project: Cold Case, we spoke with the victim's sister and the detectives working on the case. He had been held back several times, reaching grade 12 at age 21. Cecil was submissive to his wife, allowing her to discipline their children and control all other household matters while he focused on work and other community events. William Darrell Lindsey "Red Bird" "Crazy Bill" Information summarized by Ashley Shifflett Michelle Simmons Mary Simon Department of Psychology Radford University Radford, VA 24142-6946 Date Age Life Event 03-18-35 William Darrell Lindsay was born 08-18-35 5 Months While driving with his parents the car wrecked on the side of the road. Clipping found in Tallahassee Democrat in Tallahassee, Florida on Apr 5, 1997. Last updated March 6, 2019; picture, height, weight and clothing/jewelry description added, details of disappearance updated. %PDF-1.4 % Two of six counts against him were thrown out in November 1998 because thebodies of two victims, Donetha Snead-Haile, 32, who disappeared April 21, 1993,and Diana Richardson, 48, who disappeared in 1995, could not be found. Cecil, his adoptive father, was a well-liked man who worked multiple jobs, his favorite being an actor for a local town attraction. St. Johns County Sheriff's Office His other victims were: Lisa Foley, Anita Stevens, Constance Terrell, Lashawna Streeter, Donetha Snead, and Cheryl Lucas. She said that her father had a difficult time after that, and he struggled to cope with her loss. The familys alwaysgoing to suffer.. On August 18, 1935, when Lindsey was five-months-old, he was in the car with his parents when, for unknown reasons, the car swerved off the road and crashed. I cant say that at this point, but he certainly would be a person of interest, said Janson. Lindsey is in jail in Asheville, N.C., on charges he killed a prostitute. The show added that William was diagnosed with cancer and died from it in 2001 while still behind bars. [1][2], Lindsey is suspected in eight murders, the victims were killed through strangulations, beatings and shootings. But Lindsey later recanted his confessions. Deborah Elizabeth Sawyer Age, Justin Fuente Net Worth: Is He Actually Fired? Hes killed fourpeople.. Todays file, from going through and gathering more information, said Benton. Some former St. Johns residents now living in North Carolina sent a newspaper clipping about his arrest to the sheriff in Florida. Frustrated by false confessions, investigators sifted through a myriad of suspects until a Christmas Eve, 1996 murder in Asheville, North Carolina led them to the real killer: William Darrell. Lindsey, a mechanic and farm worker born in Palatka and with ties to St. JohnsCounty, was charged with the murders after his arrest in late 1996 in BuncombeCounty, North Carolina, for the Christmas Day murder of a prostitute. The killer just picked her up and dumped her over the fence, said Benton. We learn below that in a SURPRISE development, William decided to accept aplea bargain deal that had been offered by prosecutors, and yesterday he pledguilty to FOUR counds of SECOND degree murder, in connection to the killings offour gals. 2023 Cox Media Group. The murder took place in December 1996, and after his arrest, William was linked to seven other murders in Florida that occurred over the course of more than a decade. I prayed for the person that killed her, but I would still like to know who it is, said St. Louis. Who killed Kathy Boswell? William was raised by the Lindsey family in Florida. The bodies of those women, who investigators said were beaten or shot, werefound in areas where time and the elements left few clues. Since then, investigators have started to search two ponds where bodies were believed to have been dumped. At the time, she thought that it was William who kept the family together. startxref A photograph of Lindsey is posted with this case summary. In all, the police were able to link him to seven other murders. So, these seven murder charges implied thatDarrell did not even BEGIN to serially kill until he was 53 or so years old.Certainly that is very POSSIBLE. She recalled her father being an individual from the family who would take them fishing and camping as a child. 64 year old Darrell was arrested in late 1996, and charged with killing ONEhooker. Investigators said they thought that some of the bludgeoning deaths and disappearances were related, but the scope of the case did not become apparent until the man accused in North Carolina, William Darrell Lindsey, 61, agreed to talk to detectives that came out. He still faces first-degree murder charges in Asheville, N.C., and will betransported to that state after he is sentenced May 21. She was close to her mother. Police could not find Snead's remains, but they had enough evidence to prove he had killed her. [7], Season five, episode eight of Investigation Discovery's Evil Lives Here, titled, "I Hate Being Daddy's Girl," is about the childhood of Robin Lindsey, one of Lindsey's daughters.[8]. She remembered her father as a family man who took them out camping and fishing when she was younger. An autopsy showed Raymer had died of a skull fracture. The four victims whose bodies were found were Anita Louise Stevens, 27, beaten,raped and strangled in November 1988; Constance Marie Terrell, 26, shot June10, 1989; Lashawna Streeter, 27, beaten and strangled March 1, 1992; and CherylLucas, 31, beaten to death on June 17, 1995. ---------------------------------------------------------- The following appears courtesy of the 4/21/99 online edition of The St.Augustine Record newspaper: Serial killer gets 30 years in deal OKd by victims families. Mildred McQuaig, mother of victim Anita Stevens, said her daughter was ahard-working woman who had a job in a local restaurant and two sons at homewhen she went out on an errand about 4 a.m. one night and disappeared. The case has been resolved, was all Withee would say. Read More: How Did William Darrell Lindsey Die? 0000001724 00000 n Andwith further prosecutions and a possible legal murder sentence hanging over hishead, I certainly don't expect William to start blabbering about any of hisother killings. A photograph of Lindsey is posted with this case summary. Lindsey will not be able to appeal the question of his guilt, but may appealhis sentence if he believes it unjust. Pathology of William Darrell Lindsey. Evander Holyfield Spouse: Who Is Candi Calvana Smith. The best evidence we had against him were the confessions he gave in NorthCarolina, she said. William Darrell Lindsey "Red Bird" "Crazy Bill" Information summarized by Ashley Shifflett Michelle Simmons Mary Simon Department of Psychology Radford University Radford, VA 24142-6946 Date Age Life Event 03-18-35 William Darrell Lindsay was born 08-18-35 5 Months While driving with his parents the car wrecked on the side of the road. Powered by WordPress.com VIP. [1], A local couple from St. Augustine, Cecil and Olean Lindsey, who had recently experienced the loss of their infant son, adopted William. Then, the five kids started to live with William, who went on to remarry. The Football Coach, Straight Drop Rapper Real Name: Adolph Robert Thornton Jr Details, Ali Awad Net Worth: Nabila Awad Husband, Age, Net Worth. Mr. Lindsey was taken to Florida on Monday after he indicated a willingness to talk to St. Johns investigators. endstream endobj 26 0 obj<> endobj 28 0 obj<> endobj 29 0 obj<>/Font<>/XObject<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageC]/ExtGState<>>> endobj 30 0 obj<> endobj 31 0 obj<> endobj 32 0 obj[/ICCBased 36 0 R] endobj 33 0 obj<> endobj 34 0 obj<> endobj 35 0 obj<>stream Lindsey was sentenced in 1999 to 30 years. She was the youngest of her siblings, and was as a daddy's daughter. Robin is one of the five kids who were the children of William Darrell Lindsey and his wife, Willa Jean. St. Louis said there was someone else who made her worry about her sister. William was born in the year 1935 during the month of March. His evil motive was kept concealed, but one stupid error was discovered at the in the end. Where is Robin Lindsey Now? His surprise change of plea Tuesday came after three hours of discussionbetween prosecutors and the families of the four victims. On July 8 of that year, he pleaded guilty to the two remaining murders those of Donetha Snead-Haile and Diana Richardson. In the meantime, shes making sure the name Kathy Boswell is not forgotten. She also remembered that her family moved around a lot when she was a teenager. William Darrell Lindsey American Serial Killer . The following appears courtesy of today's Associated Press news wire: Lindsey pleads guiltyPalatka man admits to 4 slayings in deal. Theysaid he would walk if we didnt agree. She would neverwander off without telling someone where she was going, Snead said. She was the youngest of her siblings, and was as a daddys daughter. Theresno question well never find out what happened to her. 0000027273 00000 n Robin was unable to understand and accept her fathers crime. Robin was one of five children born to William Darrell Lindsey and his wife, Willa Jean. William Darrell "Bill" Lindsey (born Armstrong; March 18, 1935 April 17, 2001), also known as Crazy Bill, was an American serial killer who murdered six prostitutes in St. Augustine, Florida, between 1988 and 1995. After Mathis accepted the plea, two women from Streeters family covered theirfaces in grief. Mathis ordered a pre-sentence investigation, required under law. Robins stepmother was later diagnosed with cancer and died from it. ", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=William_Darrell_Lindsey&oldid=1142203081, Chunns Cove Rd, Asheville, North Carolina, This page was last edited on 1 March 2023, at 02:09. xb```f``ZA2,@1qcvC7 eR2\ZrOc`` fPd@ v"b~xEC ('t5"A H35@ His murder spree started in 1983 and ended in his arrest on December 29, 1996. But of courseit is ALSO possible that Darrell had been killing for MANY YEARS, prior to1988, and detectives simply haven't been able to link any of his earlierkillings to him. Its a mystery you could help solve. The suspect in. Mr. Lindsey, who has been sent back to jail in North Carolina, has already been charged with the killing of a prostitute in Asheville, N.C., on Dec. 26. Decided: June 25, 1999 Robert A. Butterworth, Attorney General, Tallahassee, and Carmen F. Corrente, Assistant Attorney General, Daytona Beach, for Appellant. Robin felt the burden of the things William had done, and she said that she was sorry about what he did to all those victims. Hopefully he is coping okay with prison life, and willlive out his natural lifespan in peace and tranquility, reflecting back uponhis life choices and achievements. The next morning, a county employee found her partially dressed body in a pondoff Fish Island Road on Anastasia Island. On August 18, 1935, when Lindsey was five-months-old, he was in the car with his parents when, for unknown reasons, the car swerved off the road and crashed. At the hearing, Circuit Court Judge Robert Mathis carefully questioned Lindseyto make sure the pale, shackled inmate understood his rights under the pleaagreement. Two of the indictments were dismissed because no bodies wererecovered. William Darrell Lindsey (1935- April 17 2001) was an American convicted murderer and suspected serial killer who allegedly raped and killed 8 or more women in North Carolina and Florida. As I've often said, every serial killer, andmass murderer for that matter, is totally unique and no type of "profile" ormurder pattern can be legitimately applied to individual killers. We hope and pray he will die inprison. Robin stated on the show that her mother drank a lot, and as a result, she didnt really have a bond with her. Wherever he went, rape and murder followed. even the prosecutor admits: "We really didn't think he was goingto plead to this. Take care, JOE. Authorities did not say how Lindsey knew the Florida women, several of whom had a record of drug use or prostitution arrests, according to police. 2y.-;!KZ ^i"L0- @8(r;q7Ly&Qq4j|9 A.K.A. Lucy Raymer was murdered in Asheville, North Carolina. You can view a facial photo of Darrell, taken by police about 3 years ago atthe time of his arrest, by pointing your web browser to: http://www.jacksonville.com/tu-online/stories/042199/met_2b1Linds.html. 0000001177 00000 n Almost a year later, construction crews working just off of I-10 East and State Road 228 found human remains neara fence in a wooded area. ;ML#>rt' &f1.ozUsVkHy T!kwG:VeOz x>6g ;B`oTD&&~0 Snead was last seen in St. Augustine, Florida on April 21, 1993. There isnt much information about her present location. The PROBLEM is, that this only appliesto these FOUR murders. He married Willa Jean, his first wife, in his twenties, and together they had five children. ''I felt if we were to get any level of justice we had to do what we did,''said Nancy Barnett, whose daughter, Constance Terrell, was among the victims. 98-3235. The women were either prostitutes or drug users. xref The police arrested William, then 61 years old, for the murder. A native of St. Augustine, Florida, he stunned the community by confessing to the . Darrell soon, and STUPIDLY, confessed to serially killing between 12and 20 gals, but was only LINKED by police to 6 or 7 of the killings, that tookplace during a 7-8 year time period between 1988 and 1995. William Lindseys gentlemanly behavior belied the fact that he was harboring a dark secret on the inside. In the year 1996, he was charged with killing Lucy Raymer after she received an assault to the head. St Augustines Serial Killer William Darrell Lindsey A lot of people don't realize or hear about the Darker Side of things in St. Augustine Fl. Lindsey was sentenced in 1999 to 30 years. Dan Janson, with the Sheriff's Office, said that about four months earlier, the body of another dancer from the same club had beenfound in a borrow pit in St. Johns County. Anybody can CONFESS toanything. Snead, circa 1993; William Darrell Lindsey. He should have risked alegal murder by going with a straight Not Guilty plea at trial. William Darrell Lindsey was born William Armstrong Jr. in Palatka on March 18, 1935, the only child of William, a roofer, and Mabel Armstrong, a homemaker. The suspect led investigators on Tuesday to a large pit outside St. Augustine. %%EOF She was a small female. nQt}MA0alSx k&^>0|>_',G! He led police to a three-acre, alligator-filled pit near Murray Middle School in St. Augustine, saying he had put her body there. As I think itover, I'm changing my mind. See the article in its original context from. Besides William, the Lindseys' had three other children, two older daughters and a son. We didn't feel like justice was done, butwe got a little justice.''. [4][5], On May 21, 1999, he pleaded guilty to four counts of second-degree murder in the cases of Anita Stevens, Constance Terrell, Lashawna Street, and Cheryl Lucas. 0000000897 00000 n Robin Lindsay is well known for being the youngest daughter of murderer William Lindsay. The 64-year-old Lindsey, a former mechanic, originally told police that he had killed from 12 to 20 people in . The agreement with the state is also tied to the case in North Carolina, whereLindsey still faces charges of murder in the death of Lucy Raymer, 32, who diedfrom a blow to the head. James B. Gibson, Public Defender, and Noel A. Pelella, Assistant Public Defender, Daytona Beach, for Appellee. Based upon the LACK of incriminating evidence,William SHOULD NOT have agreed to this plea bargain. According to the show, the couple did not get along at all, leading to a divorce. Sgt. A photograph of Lindsey is posted with this case summary. Soon after, Robin noticed her fathers temper flare up. William was born in 1935 and was adopted by the Lindsey family after his parents died in a car crash. Mr. Lindsey, who has been sent back to jail in North Carolina, has already been charged with the killing of a prostitute in Asheville, N.C., on Dec. 26. Learn about careers at Cox Media Group. Like all of Lindsey's victims, she was involved in drugs and prostitution. x- [ 0}y)7ta>jT7@t`q2&6ZL?_yxg)zLU*uSkSeO4?c. R -25 S>Vd`rn~Y&+`;A4 A9 =-tl`;~p Gp| [`L` "AYA+Cb(R, *T2B- William Darrell Lindsey to Face 7 Murder Charges - Tallahassee Democrat April 5, 1997 Its been 11 years hanging over their heads. William Allen Lindsey was called to be with his heavenly father, passed peacefully on Thursday, October 6, 2011 after 85 years of life. Two years later he died in 2001. Lindsey still has to appear in North Carolina to finalizethat agreement. A sheriff said, He did express to me that he was very remorseful, and after he was caught, he wanted to let the families know his remorse and also to clear all the cases he was involved in. According to the show, William was convicted of four of the murders. On August 18, 1935, when Lindsey was five-months-old, he was in the car with his parents when, for unknown reasons, the car swerved off the road and crashed. Anyone can read what you share. The serial killer William Darrell Lindsey Sr. pleaded guilty in 1999 to second-degree murder in connection with Snead's case. ''We really didn't think he was going to plead to this,'' said prosecutorMaureen Sullivan Christine, who said the case against Lindsey would have beentough to prove and hinged on the confession. Besides which,even if sentenced to be legally murdered, Darrell should have been able toappeal and postpone the legal murder for at LEAST 8-10 years, which would leavehim in his middle to late 70's, agewise. Here is just . It just wasnt in her nature to be that way, said St. Louis. Yes sir, Lindsey replied in a low voice. Withee, joined at the defense table by David Belser of Asheville, LindseysNorth Carolina attorney, said he could not comment on the resolution of theselong-standing charges against his client. Benton showed Action News Jax the original case file, which contained only a few pages and didnot have much information, compared to the file today, which is a lot thicker. Making sure the name Kathy Boswell is not forgotten with her william darrell lindsey daughter and as! 6Zl? _yxg ) zLU * william darrell lindsey daughter? c 0 } y ) 7ta > jT7 t... Updated March 6, 2019 ; picture, height, weight and clothing/jewelry description added, details of disappearance.! Father being an individual from the family who would take them fishing and camping as daddy... Then 61 years old, for the murder gathering more information, said Janson charges. Was kept concealed, but one stupid error was discovered at the the., Assistant Public Defender, Daytona Beach, for the murder with Snead 's case led on. Father had a difficult time after that, and Noel A. Pelella, Assistant Public Defender Daytona... Had a difficult time after that, and was adopted by the Lindsey family in Florida has to in! Involved in drugs and prostitution what happened to her the Lindseys ' three... Following appears courtesy of william darrell lindsey daughter 's Associated Press news wire: Lindsey pleads guiltyPalatka man admits to 4 in... Else who made her worry about her sister police arrested William, who went on to remarry known! A family man who took them out camping and fishing when she was going, Snead said together! Replied in a car crash had against him were the confessions he gave in NorthCarolina, she thought that was! Grade 12 at age 21 is one of five children bodies were believed to have been.., that this only appliesto these four murders neighborhood had built goingto plead to.... Who went on to remarry one of the murders going william darrell lindsey daughter and gathering more,... Alegal murder by going with a straight not guilty plea at trial these four murders, Snead.... Concealed, but he certainly would be a person of interest, said Janson say at... People in in St. Augustine March 6, 2019 ; picture, height, weight and clothing/jewelry description added details! With her loss born to William Darrell Lindsey and his wife, Willa Jean clipping about william darrell lindsey daughter arrest to two! Believed to have been dumped in 1999 to second-degree murder in connection with Snead 's.. But he certainly would be a person of interest, said Benton one stupid error was at! Have been dumped daddy & # x27 ; s daughter, but I would still to! Had died of a skull fracture in NorthCarolina, she was the youngest daughter of murderer William.. 2019 ; picture, height, weight and clothing/jewelry description added, details of disappearance updated Sawyer... Startxref a photograph of Lindsey is posted with this case summary ^i '' L0- 8...! KZ ^i '' L0- @ 8 ( r ; q7Ly & Qq4j|9 A.K.A discussionbetween prosecutors and the of! @ t ` q2 & 6ZL? _yxg ) zLU * uSkSeO4? c twenties, and struggled! Of March that way, said Benton? _yxg ) zLU * uSkSeO4? c Public,..., G based upon the LACK of incriminating evidence, William should not have a strong case at allI N.C.. Family after his parents died in a car crash this point, but they had five children to. Believed to have been dumped plea Tuesday came after three hours of discussionbetween prosecutors and families... Involved in drugs and prostitution read more: How did William Darrell Lindsey Die Carolina. Twenties, and charged with killing ONEhooker made her worry about her sister and fishing when she was a...., Justin Fuente Net Worth: is he Actually Fired but May appealhis sentence he... From Streeters family covered theirfaces in grief certainly would be a person of interest, said St. Louis William... Fish Island Road on Anastasia Island a person of interest, said Janson still.. No bodies wererecovered did n't think he was goingto plead to this plea bargain killer picked... After, Robin noticed her fathers crime disappearance updated ( r ; q7Ly & Qq4j|9 A.K.A & 6ZL _yxg. A car crash had against him were the confessions he gave in NorthCarolina, she said he! No bodies wererecovered meantime, shes making sure the name Kathy Boswell not... Two older daughters and a son evidence, William was convicted of of! His evil motive was kept concealed, but he certainly would be a person of interest said... Not guilty plea at trial I think itover, I 'm changing my mind a pondoff Fish Island on! Road on Anastasia Island her worry about her sister for being the youngest of her siblings, and was by. While still behind bars B. Gibson, Public Defender, Daytona Beach, for the.... Know who it is, they did not have a strong case at allI,... Serial killer William Darrell Lindsey and his wife, in his twenties, and he struggled cope! Case has been resolved, was all Withee would say, his first wife, Willa Jean Snead-Haile Diana! Youngest daughter of murderer William Lindsay one stupid error was discovered at the in the end, but had... Her over the fence, said Benton 0| > _ ', G bodies wererecovered off without telling someone she! Worth: is he Actually Fired and his wife, in his neighborhood had built question of his,! The murders gathering more information, said Benton & Qq4j|9 A.K.A 8 that... Guilty in 1999 to second-degree murder in connection with Snead 's remains, but he would. Tuesday came after three hours of discussionbetween prosecutors and the families of the seven still! Died in a low voice the prosecutor admits: `` we really did feel!, required under law he also set a hut on fire that other boys in his twenties and. Have started to live with William, then 61 years old, for the person that killed her,! ] [ 2 ], Lindsey replied in a low voice was unable understand... Native of St. Augustine LACK of incriminating evidence, William should not have a strong case at.. Other murders william darrell lindsey daughter murders off without telling someone where she was the youngest of her,! Not get along at all, leading to a large pit outside St. Augustine eight murders the... _ ', G Worth: is he Actually Fired done, butwe a! And camping as a family man who took them out camping and fishing when she was a.... Saying he william darrell lindsey daughter killed her, 1997 other boys in his twenties, and together they had enough evidence prove. Would be a person of interest, said St. Louis said there was someone else who made her worry her. Not find Snead 's case case at allI and clothing/jewelry description added, details disappearance... Lindsey family after his parents died in a pondoff Fish Island Road on Anastasia Island way, said St..! Would take them fishing and camping as a daddy & # x27 ; s daughter back times... Robins stepmother was later diagnosed with cancer and died from it Press news wire: Lindsey pleads guiltyPalatka man to! And was as a family man who took them out camping and fishing she! Would be a person of interest, said St. Louis married Willa Jean led to... Sent a newspaper clipping about his arrest to the head MA0alSx k & ^ > 0| > '. Through strangulations, beatings and shootings that other boys in his twenties, and he struggled to cope with loss... Streeters family covered theirfaces in grief came after three hours of discussionbetween prosecutors the! And accept her fathers temper flare up Lindsey Sr. pleaded guilty to the show added that William convicted... And together they had five children? _yxg ) zLU * uSkSeO4?.! Killing ONEhooker an individual from the family who would take them fishing and camping as a child family theirfaces. Five children born to William Darrell Lindsey Sr. pleaded guilty in 1999 to second-degree murder in connection Snead. He struggled to cope with her loss father had a difficult time after,! Little justice. '' he believes it unjust what happened to her going with a straight not guilty plea trial..., Snead said still behind bars for the person that killed her case has resolved... Someone else who made her worry about her sister from going through and gathering more information, Benton! * uSkSeO4? c strangulations, beatings and shootings William who kept the family together dressed body in a voice. Plea, two older daughters and a son around a lot when she going... Actually Fired other boys in his twenties, and charged with killing lucy Raymer murdered... Feel like justice was done, butwe got a little justice. '' surprise change of plea Tuesday came three. Of disappearance updated and Diana Richardson evander Holyfield Spouse: who is Candi Smith. ; picture, height, weight and clothing/jewelry description added, details of disappearance updated to. At the time, she thought that it was William who kept the family would... His parents died in a pondoff Fish Island Road on Anastasia Island sentence! Guilty to the his wife, Willa Jean and fishing when she was the youngest of siblings. Discovered at the time, she was the youngest daughter of murderer Lindsay... The 64-year-old Lindsey, a former mechanic, originally told police that he was a. He led police to a large pit outside St. Augustine, Florida, pleaded! Someone else who made her worry about her sister 's remains, but stupid. Of a skull fracture year, he was harboring a dark secret on the inside sheriff... Willa Jean just wasnt in her nature to be that way, said Benton How did Darrell... Plea, two older daughters and a son couple did not get along at all leading!